I've finally gotten the chance to take a class that is very important to me: Introduction to Women and Gender Studies. I'm considering making Women and Gender Studies one of my majors but I wanted to wait until I took the class and experienced what it was like before declaring. The class so far is brilliant. The professor is wonderful and the reading is very important to me: whether it's an article as to why feminism isn't "dead" or whether it's a piece dispelling myths about feminism, I find everything insightful and relevant to my daily life. There is one small issue, and this is an issue that comes up for many people in many classes: some of the people in the class.
On the first day of class, we were assigned groups and ask to "find out about the other members in the group." After discussing majors and what year we were, I decided to change the discussion and make it a bit more relevant to the class. I said, "I think it's a pretty fair assumption to make, but are we all feminists?" A vital fact to mention is that my group consisted of two women and three men. The men were mostly silent or nodding, except for one that exclaimed, "I wouldn't ever call myself a FEMINIST!" with indignance. To this, I calmly responded, "Oh, then would you call yourself sexist? Because feminism mostly works for equality between sexes." He sort of shrugged and looked away.
Today, I had this class again. Apparently, this guy went to one of his friends (who openly dislikes women, namely feminists) and complained about "a short blonde girl who yelled at him about feminism." (I would like to note that, as is a misconception with feminism, my calm statement about feminism was interpreted as "yelling" and "angry.") This friend decided that it was necessary to join the class "to back his friend up." Today was his first day in class.
Throughout the class, these two thought it necessary to make homophobic, misogynistic, chauvinistic comments. When the teacher said "When white men did research on the shape of skulls and intelligence they, of course, decided that the white male had a superior skull that made them more intelligent than other genders or races." The two looked at each other and the one said, completely serious, "Sounds about right to me." The other nodded. When the teacher talked about her son that liked Broadway and wanted to be a "dance professor," the two smirked and nudged each other. After the class was over, the two thought it was necessary to point me out and laugh to each other. There were other examples, of course, but these are the ones that I recall off of the top of my head. It continued throughout the entire class.
After the class, I found myself quite upset. I go to a leading university and am generally surrounded by educated, civil people. I questioned why these people were so threatened by my simple explanation of feminism. I found my answer in some of the readings we were assigned. One reason as to why people are threatened by feminism is that people, white males in particular, don't want to lose their own supremacy. They recognize, directly or otherwise, that they have an advantage in society and don't want anyone to challenge it: let alone a strong woman. It is the same reason why there wasn't racial equality for a long time (and, in many ways, there still isn't). I also questioned why they thought that a boy liking Broadway was comical. My answer was also arrived at somewhat easily: homophobia. I read about many of the myths about feminism. One was that feminisms are just "angry women." I find it very interesting that, when men are angry, they get things done. When women are angry, it is considered abnormal and unattractive, not to mention notable. Another myth about feminists is that feminists are all lesbians. If our society wasn't so riddled by homophobia, this wouldn't prevent people from labeling themselves as feminists. Because many people still view being gay as a bad thing, however, this is off-putting to people. These are only a couple of the many negative stereotypes about feminists that exist. I would like to note that all of these issues were addressed in my textbook.
I find it very disheartening that, at a leading university, students still adhere to old and destructive stereotypes. There are men in my class that honestly think that, to be worth anything, you must be a white male (or so it seemed, by their words and by their actions). It's obvious to me that, even in our day and age, we must still work for equality: whether it's equality between sexes, between races, or between sexual orientations. I hope that, within the course, some of their beliefs are dispelled and disproven. In the meantime, I hope that their negative attitudes and belief systems are just that, and that they don't take actions based on their own harmful attitudes. I also hope that you are all working for equality in your lives! Wish me luck.
http://www.amplifyyourvoice.org/u/vanessaaishacoleman/2009/10/21/Rape-is-not-a-punchline
I totally relate to your second comment. In high school and now in college, I often hear people joking around that they got "raped" or that they're going to rape something or someone. One person's facebook status was "O Chem just raped me in the ass without lube!" Seriously? Rape isn't in any way, shape, or form comical... it's so discouraging. Good luck with your situation as well!
I agree there are fools who think like this. However, from what I have seen here on campus in the bible belt, this is NOT an adequate description of white males who have low opinions of feminists. There are religious reasons why men may not support feminism. Putting the religious objectors aside, I can tell you that the remainder generally don't have a problem with women having equal rights and opportunities. Losing a sense of supremacy does not capture what they're feeling. They're feeling under attack, that the ordinary guy is being made out to be an evil oppressor of women. And because their personal beliefs are in stark contrast to this characterization, they become bitter and more than a little cynical about feminism. They view feminists not as activists working for equality, but as men-haters working on special status and preferential treatment for women. In that sense, they view feminism as an industry that today exists more for the sake of existing than it does for any worthwhile goals; i.e. feminists are drumming up controversy and divisiveness so they can “stay in business”, as it were. So, from what I've seen, men who would otherwise be supporters of feminism are instead alienated by it. And that’s too bad because women are still some distance away from true equality.
"I find it very interesting that, when men are angry, they get things done. When women are angry, it is considered abnormal and unattractive, not to mention notable."
Men are "powerful" or "strong." Women are just "bitchy" or "PMS."
Second- Brak, here's an article you might find interesting. It's about finding a more positive masculinity to fit into this new world where the concepts of femininity and gender roles are so new and different in some ways (although obviously not in others).
http://carnalnation.com/content/38206/44/masculinity-doesnt-hurt
On a related note, I'm very interested in the idea of positive masculinity. We had a speaker come to my college who spoke on a movie he spoke in and briefly on a book he wrote, "Getting Off: Pornography and the End of Masculinity." If you're interested, his name is Robert Jensen. I think he raises some important issues and has a unique perspective on the matter.
I also agree with your ideas about why men might feel alienated. I think there have been certain radical "men-hating" feminists that, unfortunately, got a lot more attention than others, as is typical of very outspoken people in society. These women held certain beliefs...and also identified as feminists. Now, feminists are automatically assumed to hold the same beliefs. This doesn't just apply to the way men might understand feminism either. Many women don't want to identify as feminists because they'll be "bra-burning femi-nazis." As you said, it is quite unfortunate because women do still have a long way to go in terms of equality. People can argue it as much as they like, but the statistics still show an alarming trend.
I'd encourage you to talk to your professor/instructor. Share this link with them (if you are comfortable enough) and aks if there's any guidance or class expectations she can discuss with the class as a group. Sometimes instructors are not trained to manage classes such as these, and it is a challenge. However, that is part of our job as professors: to create an environment where peopl can share their opinions in a way that does not oppress and/or disrespect other students or the instructor. I very much think this is a classroom facilitation issue, and one that if your instructor can moderate can be a good discussion.
I hope this experience does not make you believe that your voice and opinions don't matter. If you at any time, think your physical and mental safety is being comprimised I encourage you to talk to a trusted adult at the university (counseling center, departmetn chair, advisor etc.) because it is your RIGHT (and every other students) to be safe in acquiring new knowledge, and hopefully you expect to be challenged (which is very differnt from being threatened).
pardon my spelling errors i can't figure out how to spell check!
I felt a little childish "telling" on them, but I do feel as though this behavior can make for an uncomfortable climate. I figured that, if I was this uncomfortable, other students must be as well. I didn't name any names, but the professor is now aware of the situation and will hopefully be able to monitor it closely. Thanks again for your advice! Hopefully it will all work out well and their own ideas will be challenged and improved upon!