LOG IN   JOIN   BLOG SEARCH   ALL DIARIES

Website Blog
Blog
Issues
Take Action
Videos
Donate
About
Youth Resources
My Sistahs
Advocates For Youth
In The Culture - Read More
Blog - Amplify your voice

Monday, June 28, 2010 at 8:03:00 AM EDT

It's real. It's fleshy and short and caramel-colored and honestly, it's bigger and lumpier and weaker than I wish it was just now. But that's my business. I can do some things about that or not to a certain extent. How much I care varies from day to day. You can think I'm fine or a fat slob, that's your business, whether I like it or not. But what you cannot do, what you should never even wish you could do, is torture my body or anyone else's in order to get rich selling an impossible fairytale about bodies on the teevee, and then pretending It's All True and if the rest of us can't measure up, we just don't want it badly enough. Or, rather, I suppose you can, but you will burn in Hell for doing it. And I don't even believe in Hell.

I've been sick to my stomach for weeks reading Golda Poretsky's three-part interview with Kai Hibbard, a former finalist on NBC's weight-loss boot camp aspirational reality show, The Biggest Loser. It's gut-wrenching (pun intended) and I can't urge you strongly enough to read the whole thing, but let me bottom-line it for you here: that feel-good show about fat people literally re-forming their sad bodies (and by extension, sad lives) through steely determination, exercise and a healthy diet? It's a lie. The whole thing. Start-to-finish. A "week" isn't a week (sometimes it's as long as 14 days), inspiring trainers are actually terrifying dictators more concerned with tv-friendly results than the eating disorders they're instilling, and triumphs of will are really stories about captives gritting through the torture of working out for up to 7 hours dangerously dehydrated and on serious injuries.

In other words? In order to sell us the fairytale that every body can look the same if we all just work hard enough to be healthy, NBC and the producers of this show create a completely unattainable ideal and, in the process, blithley hobble the health of the very "average Americans" we're supposed to emulate.

And on the heels of that, this fresh dump crapped out by Dove, supposed champion of "real" women, casting for their next ad campaign, looking for only "real" women with "FLAWLESS SKIN, NO TATTOOS OR SCARS! Well groomed and clean...Nice Bodies..NATURALLY, FIT Not too Curvy Not too Athletic."

So, dear Unilever, dear NBC, dear Jillian Michaels, dear anyone else who's ever tried to sell me fictional "health" in order to make me feel like a failure so that I'll buy more of your crap: Eff you. You can be my fake friend all day and all night, and I'll still see you for who you really are: the enemy of my strength. And don't be mistaken: I'm getting stronger every day. And I'm not alone.There are legions of us who are stronger than ever, strong enough to know that any food we can swallow is better for us than your lies. We reject social acceptance if we have to be broken or controlled to get it. We know that verbal abuse isn't love, scars don't have to be flaws, and less weight doesn't always equal more health. And we're telling. We're whispering these secrets into more ears every day. We're shouting them from rooftops where we can.

You want to watch a number get smaller and smaller? Just count the days left you have in power.

Share this entry:  del.icio.us | Facebook |  MySpace | Digg It! | Tweet This
Comments
Excellent post!
# Posted By  jujufruit | 6/28/10 10:17 AM | Report | Reply
 wow. what a beautiful post. so powerful--thank you for sharing this. 
# Posted By AFY_Viviana | 6/28/10 11:16 AM | Report | Reply
Way to call it, Jacklyn.  I had hoped that the Barbi myth was slipping in its grip on women, but apparently not. 
# Posted By rogercanaff | 6/28/10 02:08 PM | Report | Reply
 This is brilliant! I've been thinking a lot about how others view my body lately, mostly because, despite now sitting at a healthy weight a la Beyonce from a younger natural body type of Calista Flockhart until 2 years ago. It really changed the way I looked at myself, and it's been difficult. I probably have more muscle mass now than I did back then, and I'm a pretty fit person, but even I stare at the end of Biggest Loser that somehow in 6 months, these folks go from trouble walking to running a marathon faster than me, and I've been running for years!  I had the amazing chance to be a part of an interview with Sunshine and O'Niell (that was featured on the show this past season, I worked for that radio station), and they are both outstanding people, but they seemed exercise obsessed to me! And maybe, for a season, that can be okay, but it didn't seem like  they expected the brutality to end after the show, even if it were self-enforced. 
On the secondary Dove campaign thing: Amen!  I have 13 tattoos: some cover physical scars (a 3rd degree burn), some cover emotional ones. But my tattoos had a surprising effect:  my body was no longer the blank canvas of everyone else's imagination, my body became mine. 

# Posted By  Lklouise | 6/28/10 02:31 PM | Report | Reply
 mmm awesome Lklouise :) This is one of the most powerful (maybe for me personally haha) i've read on here. thank you
# Posted By AFY_Viviana | 6/28/10 02:46 PM | Report | Reply
I love it when you say, " my body was no longer the blank canvas of everyone else's imagination, my body became mine." That is great for you. Keep it up.
# Posted By RyAnYWOC | 7/1/10 10:28 PM | Report | Reply
GREAT POST!!! Jaclyn, I loved your book Yes Means Yes, as well, I read it in my Women's and Gender Class.
# Posted By RyAnYWOC | 7/1/10 10:31 PM | Report | Reply
Amen!  These shows are awful, and clearly geared at, as you put it, selling us crap:
dear anyone else who's ever tried to sell me fictional "health" in order to make me feel like a failure so that I'll buy more of your crap: Eff you
As a man, I see this all the time...a picture of a ripped, tan guy on the beach with some beautiful girls selling beer, deodorant, etc, basically saying "buy our produts and you will be a real man."  Bullshit. 

But using a fictional health standard to sell products is even more damaging, and SO irresponsible.


# Posted By  dandaman6007 | 7/5/10 01:26 PM | Report | Reply

During all of high school, due to my medication, I was very skinny. However, when I got to college, the combination of Sodexho and beer made me have a big belly. I had become depressed over my weight, but surprisingly, around the time I made my psychological transition to female, I was OK with being a little chubby, and even marched in Philadelphia with my blouse open.

# Posted By  Jordan | 7/5/10 07:42 PM | Report | Reply