LOG IN   JOIN   BLOG SEARCH   ALL DIARIES

Website Blog
Blog
Issues
Take Action
Videos
Donate
About
Youth Resources
My Sistahs
Advocates For Youth
In The Culture - Read More
Blog - Amplify your voice

Monday, February 22, 2010 at 1:27:00 PM EST

I'll be honest: I'm not really a sports fan. There isn't a single sport I follow on a regular basis. (Back before the Red Sox won the World Series, I'd get invested whenever they made the playoffs, because I can't resist an underdog narrative, but that's about it.)

But between the Super Bowl brouhaha and the relentlessly addictive Olympics broadcasts, I've been watching a lot of sports and sports commentary in 2010. And as hard as it is to resist getting sucked into one of those soft-focus tinkly-piano Olympic athlete backstories, it's equally difficult to avoid noticing how retro our gender and sex politics get when it comes to sports.

It goes almost without saying that the Super Bowl has has a messed up relationship with women and sex. But men's figure skating? Women's snowboarding? Ski jumping? Downhill skiing? In 2010? Sadly, yes. To wit, just a few of the nearly infinite offenses from the past week of the Olympics:

-When introducing a profile of the top three female U.S. snowboarders - who happen to be three of the top women's snowboarders in the world, and were favorites to sweep the medals in halfpipe - NBC Olympics anchor Bob Costas didn't praise their incredible strength, crazy hard work over so many years, or the daredevil bravery it takes to get to the top of a sport like halfpipe snowboarding. No. Instead, Costas turned them into modern-day Charlie's Angels:

They are of course rivals, but they're also friends. Each with a defining aspect to their character. Kelly Clark's spirit, Hannah Teter's generosity, and the winning glamor of Gretchen Bleiler.

-At least the female snowboarders get to compete. Women's ski jumping is still not an Olympic sport, because officials are too concerned that it will hurt our fragile ladyparts! (They claim it's also because the sport isn't big enough worldwide, but it's bigger than ski cross, which got added to the Olympics this year. A sport that looks a LOT more dangerous than ski jumping, but actually allows delicate, fragile ladies to compete. Imagine!)

-The Sports Illustrated swimsuit edition for 2010 features four (white, U.S., and no, I'm not linking to it) female Olympic athletes, including aforementioned snowboard champion Hannah Teter (posing in a bikini for S.I. is evidently still not enough to get you called the glamorous one?), and skiing phenom Lindsey Vonn, who overcame a painful injury to win gold in downhill. But that's evidently not the most compelling thing about her. Google "Lindsey Vonn skiier," you get 4,560,000 hits. Lindsey Vonn pictures? 5,960,000.

-Lest you think the Olympic men get a free pass, consider men's figure skating, where bitter silver medalist Evgeni Plushenko has been essentially (and very publicly) questioning the manhood of gold medalist Evan Lysacek, all because he managed to win by focusing on footwork and other less "butch" technical skills, at the expense of landing the uber-masculine (I guess?) quad jump. Is it any wonder that even the most flamboyant skater men's skating has ever seen - the incomparable Johnny Weir - refuses to discuss his sexuality in any way?

In Slate this week, Hannah Rosin argued that at least Vonn's bikini-clad romp features an adult woman actively owning her sexuality, as opposed to the more traditional Olympic eye-candy featuring 16-year-old glitter pixies on ice. There's some truth to that, though I'm not sure that posing doe-eyed for SI is exactly the highest bar for empowered sexuality.

Still, it's not surprising that sexuality, gender and sports are all tangled up. It's not even necessarily a bad thing - would we want a culture in which we collectively and intently focus our attention to an activity involving tight clothes, strong, fluid bodies, emotional passion and physical exertion, but we're not allowed to think about gender and sex? I wouldn't. But I do want a culture where more than four of the over 5,000 athletes competing at the Olympics this year feel comfortable being out as queer. (And one where any male athletes could be out would also be an improvement.) Where there are more choices than princess or vixen, stud or fag. Where female athletes get more attention for their accomplishments than for their looks, and aren't prevented from competing in the sport of their choice because we'd rather think of them as delicate sex objects than as world-class athletes.

It would be easy to let the Olympics off the hook, to argue that they just reflect the sexual culture we're living in. But, according to their own propaganda, the Olympics are supposed to be an aspirational event. A time for the world to come together to transcend our differences and limitations and embody a vision of how we could be. My vision is this: it's well past time to hold them to that when it comes to sex and gender.

Share this entry:  del.icio.us | Facebook |  MySpace | Digg It! | Tweet This
Comments
I'm sorry, but as a woman, I think it's kind of weak to critique another woman (or anyone) for their appearances ... especially when they are good looking and do things that others perceive as "flaunting" it. I think it's incredibly sophomoric, because you are not focusing on the more substancial aspects of their talent, regardless of what the rest of the world does.

Also, you have the word "butch" in quotes when talking about Plushenko and Lysacek, which implies that you are quoting Plushenko. I love sports, I love the Olympics, and I have been watching as many events and commentary as I can, and I never heard Plushenko call what he did "butch." Where did you read that Plushenko said that? All I heard was that he said Lysacek shouldn't have won because he didn't attempt a quad. Lets be honest: Lysacek skated better, tighter, and cleaner; and Plushenko looked like a wobbling top on the ice and almost fell a few times. All that conflict reeks of sour grapes to me.

# Posted By seriously1988 | 2/22/10 03:00 PM | Report | Reply
seriously-

I didn't put "butch" in quotes because it's a direct quote from Plushenko. I used those quotes to suggest that "butch" is a contested concept - to communicate that even though the subtext of Plushenko's public comments are that the quad is what makes men's figure skating "manly" (see, I'm doing it there again in the same way - I don't think that "manly" is a term with an agreed-upon definition, so I'm qualifying it by using quotes), I don't really buy into those kinds of labeling. I'm maybe guilty of being a little snarky, but I'm not putting words into anyone's mouth.

As for critiquing a woman for her appearance - I don't see where I did that. I'm critiquing the ways the culture discusses, packages, and consumes women's appearances, the way women are encouraged to appear, not the women themselves. I also didn't use "flaunting" - but you put that in quotes, so I suspect you know exactly the way I meant "butch," too..

# Posted By Yes_Means_Yes | 2/22/10 03:43 PM | Report | Reply
Lets be honest, there is not a whole lot that is "butch" about men's figure skating, even the "butch" one who did the quad (who looks like Ellen Degeneres and Adrien Brody's lovechild).

If you are not really a sports fan and don't understand it, then why comment on it at all? I don't think these accomplished athetes would like their success diminished by politicking it to death.

# Posted By seriously1988 | 2/23/10 01:57 AM | Report | Reply
I agree with you about figure skating not being particularly "butch" in general, which is one of the reasons I put the word in quotes to begin with. I'm not sure in what ways you actually disagree with what I'm saying?
# Posted By Yes_Means_Yes | 2/23/10 04:18 PM | Report | Reply
Great post! It is good to get some real analysis of the potential biases at the Olympics. It is unfortunate how gender and sexuality plays it self out in the often public world of sports. One thing that is interesting however (but may be pointless) is to wonder if it is representing an extreme of American gender and sexuality opinions or something that is closer to the reality. The reason I say that is because I am thinking back to the Caster Semanya gender debacle as an example and the sexism against women tennis players.  I am not sure if gender and sex in sports is in some sort of hyperdimorphism or hypersexuality or if its actually a less hyperbolized representation of our society/culture?
# Posted By  vanessaaishacoleman | 2/23/10 08:33 PM | Report | Reply