I'm going to sound old for a moment. I promise it's in service of something good, so bear with me, OK? Here goes:
I am so thankful that I grew up before the widespread use of the internet, blogs and online social networking. (Heck, I didn't even have email until college. Yes, I'm really that old.) You know why? Because when I grew up and started trying to be taken seriously as a professional, there was no digital trail of my youth to hold me back. And I assure you - there would have been a trail.
Would I have sexted my high school boyfriend, Andy? Would I have sent him explicit emails and NSFW pictures of myself? You bet I would have. I wanted to have sex with Andy all the time, every day, but between parental supervision and the hour drive that separated us, we got to be together in private a lot less than that. We would have been thrilled to have digital means to get it on with each other. (As it was, I was only allowed to talk with him for 10 minutes every day. This was before cell phones, too, and there was only one line in my house. I told you I was old.)
Would Andy have deliberately shared my private messages with anyone? I doubt it. He was a pretty good guy. But he miiiight have shown a little sample to his BFF Tom, just to brag a little. And Tom miiiiiight have decided to play a practical joke on Andy by stealing the photo or message and posting it to his Facebook wall. You see where I'm going with this.
But let's say that didn't happen. Let's say Tom couldn't figure out how to steal the photo, or Andy never showed it to him, or I never sent it. Let's say I got through high school with nary a pixel's indication that I'm anything but sexually pure. But then, at college, I decide to start keeping a blog of my life on campus - including my dating exploits. Or maybe I decide to write for the school paper, and I put together a first-person expose of an underground sexual culture on campus. I write about sexuality all the time now - it's not hard to imagine I would have done it then. And that's exactly what one Harvard student did - he wrote a very popular piece for the Crimson about his "use of Craigslist to look for sex with closeted Harvard jocks." Now, according to this story about him that aired on On The Media in December, he's legally changing his name so that he can become a teacher without that article haunting him. Here's what he had to say about the decision:
[The Crimson article] was a big hit. It’s my number one Google result, of course. But now, you know, three years later, I find that I'd really like to be an elementary school teacher. So I'm really wary of the possibility of that, you know, a 10-year-old kid coming across this, because, you know, if I were, like, in fourth grade I'd be googling my teachers all the time...
I picture a kid saying, I googled you last night and I found a really funny article or a really weird article. I picture losing my authority, in some ways, you know. I feel like I would have made a joke of myself in front of my students. There’s parents googling. I mean, I guess that’s another huge fear.
And even if I were hired by a school that was really understanding and might take the position of, well, you know, he was in college and things happen, I don't really want to put any of my future employers in that position, of having to defend that.
Lesbians and gays, and BDSMers, for example, are common enough to benefit from visibility. Like the tattoo issue, it's impossible to marginalize a third of a generation if they insist on standing up. But folks who have trans histories, or who are asexual -- anyone whose experiences are demographic outliers -- won't the effect be to make them even more isolated; giving them a choice between being silent when everyone else can speak freely or speaking freely and being the only X that anyone in their social circle knows?
Its great to hear a slightly older person's perspective on this, because I constantly take all the technology I use for granted and too often assume that things I post on the internet are private. Almost always, its the opposite that is true.
Luckily, most of my professional work has been in science, and I don't see why anyone would be offended with my volunteerism within my job sector. But I do understand the Harvard student's discomfort. Sad!
Another bigger "shocker" he used was the MySpace page of a woman who discussed her childhood of sexual abuse. OMG! How could she put that on the INTERNET?!? She was abused and made to keep a horrible secret for years and years and she's finally decided to stand up for herself and share her story and connect with other women who suffered similarly-- HOW COULD SHE? She must be too STUPID to know that this information is available to everyone.
I wonder if in a few years he will be embarrassed by the information he's put out their about himself, namely that he's some kind of misogynist homophobe who believes in maintaining a culture of oppression?
I'm a female to male transsexual. I also live as a gay man. I vlog openly about all aspects of my life on Youtube and I even put up porn on Xtube. What does all this say about me? It means I'm a person. It means I'm honest. It means I'm not afraid or ashamed. It means I believe in myself and what I stand for. If people are threatened by that-- fine. But that's still who I am whether 10 people know or 10 million.