Act
In The Culture
Issues
Campaigns
Support
About
Advocates For Youth
In The Culture - Read More
Blog - Amplify your voice

Monday, August 24, 2009 at 8:51:00 AM EDT
Rating:

Quick: what do Kourtney Kardashian and President Obama have in common? It's not just their questionable fashion sense. No, both of them have recently been pressured out of choosing abortion before they could even properly consider it.

You may have heard that the young reality star is unexpectedly pregnant. But did you know why she's decided to have the baby? "My doctor told me there is nothing you will ever regret about having the baby, but he was like, 'You may regret not having the baby.'" reported Kardashian to People magazine. Because who ever regrets becoming responsible for an entire person when a) they had in no way been planning on it and b) they could have had a routine surgical procedure instead? And while Kourtney's doc may have been working overtime on the Guilt Train, her boyfriend had already laid enough groundwork ahead of time that he didn't have to lift a finger. Says Kourtney: "I think if I had said I'm not going to keep it, I really think he would have pushed me into keeping it." What every girl wants -- a partner who so obviously doesn't respect her bodily autonomy, he doesn't even have to bother saying so.

At least Kardashian's rich. She can afford the best care for her kid even if her babydaddy bails, and, if she had actually been allowed to choose an decided to have an abortion, she certainly could have afforded one. Not so for many, many American women, for whom abortion is literally not an option if their insurance doesn't cover it - or if they don't have insurance at all. That's why the Kardashian family doctor isn't winning my Enemy of Autonomy award this week. That honor, sadly, goes to President Obama, who last week told Katie Couric, "I think we also have a tradition of, in this town, historically, of not financing abortions as part of government funded health care. Rather than wade into that issue at this point, I think that it's appropriate for us to figure out how to just deliver on the cost savings, and not get distracted by the abortion debate at this station."

In other words, forcing women to give birth because they're poor and have no other options is a tradition in this country (too true), and trying to change that tradition would be a distraction. Didn't we also have, until recently, a tradition of having only white men as President?

Which brings me to another American tradition - the tradition of erasing abortion from our TV and movies.  

The recent refusal by Fox to air an episode of Family Guy b/c it dealt with the dreaded a-word is just the latest in a long history of elisions (and mind you, Fox never blinks an eye when Family Guy makes rape jokes on the regular, but abortion? That's going TOO FAR.). Whether the subject is avoided because the pregnant character miscarries before she can abort (Grey's Anatomy), decides against abortion -- often without ever uttering the word (Juno, Army Wives, The Secret Life of the American Teenager, Sex and the City, The O.C., ), or gets an abortion but gets killed off afterward (Jack & Bobby), the message is clear - when it comes to abortion, good girls not only don't do it, they don't even speak of it. The movie Knocked Up even invented the word "shmashmortion" so the characters could discuss the option at all - and as we all know, in the end, Katherine Heigl's driven career woman oh-so-realistically decided to keep the baby and co-parent with her schlub of a one-night-stand instead of doing that.

This silence isn't just making for lame euphemisms and cringe-worthy TV.  It's sending the message that abortion -- a procedure that nearly half of all U.S. women will have in their lifetimes -- is so controversial, so utterly transgressive, that we dare not even speak of it. (Josh Schwartz, creator of The O.C., said exactly that when explaining to the New York Times why he left the word out of his scripts: "The show would sink under the weight of it.'') It's enabling Kourtney Kardashian's boyfriend and doctor - and people just like them across the country - to make sure that sex always has "consequences" for women, so that we remain afraid of it and can be controlled by that fear. It's providing cover for politicians (including, unfortunately, our current President) who are more concerned about their approval ratings than women's lives. It's forcing girls and women to give birth to children against their will, making it harder for poor families to support themselves, and often putting women's health at risk.

Fox execs have admitted that they yanked the episode out of fear of an advertiser backlash. Perhaps next time a show gives abortion the silent treatment, we should show them what an advertiser backlash really looks like.

Comments
Very interesting post about the absence of abortion from the media yet things such as rape, murder and even incest can be referred to in a joking manner. This is definitely a great post.

Although, I have to say though that the comment about obama and the US having a tradition of having white presidents made me feel uncomfortable as a person of color and I am still trying to figure out why. I guess somwhere in there I feel a hint of something I have been pick up in other places lately. What I mean is sometimes I feel like bringing up Obama's race is sometimes used as a way of people to get him to take up the issues they are interested in. For example, Obama should bring up abortions because this is a touchy issue and he should be taking up on all touchy issues because somehow he owes that to us because after all we elected the first black president  and he would not be able to have gotten to that office as a black man of course if it was not for our support. Its like yes thats true but theres also something disturbing about that line of thought. Anyway I am sure that is not what you meant. Great post!
# Posted By  vanessaaishacoleman | 8/24/09 05:13 PM | Report | Reply
Oh and I made a mistake in that comment, I meant to say in the 6th sentence "For example, Obama should bring up issue X because we as a constituency voted for him so he could taken issue X (among other things) because with out our support of course he could have never made and won as a black president."
# Posted By  vanessaaishacoleman | 8/24/09 05:15 PM | Report | Reply
Vanessa-

Thanks for your comment! I hear you about talking about Obama's race - it's not actually what I was going for, but obviously I should have made my point more clearly. I brought it up not because he "owes" us something, but because I was surprised he would make an argument based on what's "traditional" in Washington, since his presence there so obviously shatters a lot of traditions.

But again, I clearly should have explained myself better.

Anyhow, thanks for reading!

-Jaclyn

# Posted By JaclynF | 8/24/09 10:05 PM | Report | Reply
Yes of course! And speaking of distractions, I totally did not mean to take away from the main issue here which is the blacklisting of abortion in the media and the healthcare debate. You have brought up a great point that I wish more people were talking about right now.
Thanks for that

# Posted By  vanessaaishacoleman | 8/25/09 08:57 AM | Report | Reply
Abortion! Abortion! Abortion!
"Fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself."
# Posted By Mahayana | 8/27/09 09:52 PM | Report | Reply
"Fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself."  Is that from "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets"?  Or was Hermione quoting somebody else?  Whatever, the quote totally applies here.

Except, I don't think "Juno" is guilty of perpetuating film & TV's attitude toward abortion.  Abortion is discussed blatantly by several of the characters, and Juno is all set to do it.  She walks totally by herself right into that clinic and is filling out the paperwork and everything.  She just got nervous and bailed at the last minute.  It irritates me to hear people talk about how "Juno" is a pro-life or a pro-choice movie.  It's neither, it's just a story.  And a gutsy one at that.

But anyway, yeah.  Agree with the whole thing.  Outrageous.

# Posted By PurpleLibertine | 9/1/09 02:06 PM | Report | Reply
You know, I don't think Juno is as bad as some of the others, but they really made that clinic seem horrible, scary, and like it didn't give a crap about the women they were serving. It really painted abortion as a very scary option, which given the paucity of other images on film & TV about what abortion might be like, is a dangerous and harmful thing to be putting out there, esp. when the reality of most family planning clinics is quite different.
# Posted By JaclynF | 9/2/09 10:17 AM | Report | Reply
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31          
Goodbyes & Hellos
By Music_And_Musings
0 comments

Abstience Comes to Albuquerque
By lexitexas
0 comments

dumb notes. don't read.
By snorkamaiden
0 comments

Respect, Empower, Include: Some Lessons from RootsCamp
By AFY_Nikki
0 comments

"Ghetto" Mothers and Their Newborn Are Denied Comprehensive Maternal Health Care in Jamaica
By Nekeisha
0 comments

Inspired in Albany-Latino AIDS Activists Unite!
By AFY_Sarah
0 comments

san francisco! where great things are combined
By Leightd
0 comments

Teen Health Now Event: Online Organizing and Advocacy Training for Youth!
By dandaman6007
0 comments

My Belief About Sex
By susanacuellar
0 comments

Phenomenally, Phenomenal Women
By elizabeth
0 comments

Kenyan Men Arrested for Attempting Gay Marriage
By vanessaaishacoleman
0 comments

While in DC...
By tillyrose
2 comments

District of Columbia has the World's First Female Football Coach
By kirbygirl87
2 comments

Commodity for Sale
By justifiable
1 comments

Vatican Doesn't Believe in Safe Sex: Condom Machines "Trivalize Sexuality"
By kirbygirl87
1 comments

Sorry, No More Antiretroviral Drugs For You
By AFY_Durryle
2 comments

International Women Day in Ethiopia
By Mery
0 comments

The Celluloid Ceiling
By Culture_Voyeur
1 comments

What Do We Know About Open Relationships?
By Media_Justice
0 comments

Know your options. Respect them!
By Aye
0 comments

Naruto Shippuden!
By narutoandsoniclover
1 comments

A Step Backwards
By addiszemen
1 comments

Beijing +15
By pedlarm
1 comments

To abort? or not to abort? That is the question
By KarachiYWOCLC
3 comments

HIROSHIMA IMAGES-1 more to come.
By snorkamaiden
0 comments