Act
In The Culture
Issues
Campaigns
Support
About
Advocates For Youth
Who was robbed at this year's Oscars?
Avatar for Best Picture
Gabby Sidibe
Up in the Air for Adapted Screenplay
Anna Kendrick for Supporting Actress
Fantastic Mr. Fox for Best Animation
Johnny Weir! Still bitter.

You must be logged in to vote.
You must be logged in to vote




My Sistahs - A webite by and for young women of color
Youth Resource - A website by and for lgbtq youth
Advocates for Youth - A website for parents, health professionals and educators
AmbienteJoven.org 
Blog - Amplify your voice

Wednesday, February 10, 2010 at 8:57:00 AM EST
Rating:

Where do you draw the thin line between prostitution and pornography? Does the presence of a camera really make that much of a difference? At the end of the day, aren’t you still getting paid to have sex with someone? If a female prostitute films herself having sex and then gets arrested for prostitution, could she really get the charges dropped if she said she was an independent film maker? Seriously, what’s the difference? Why is one illegal and the other isn’t? Why is getting paid for sex okay when it’s on a film set, but not okay when it’s in the back of a car.

Why are “adult film actors” seen as stars while prostitutes are seen as dirty? Why has pornography become so mainstream and destigmatized while prostitution remains relatively taboo? Why is being a porn star viewed as glamorous (even a fashion trend) while prostitution isn’t more than skanky? Could it just be that porn “actors” make more money?

Also, are porn “actors” considered sex workers, and if not, why not? Why is Hugh Hefner a hero, but a pimp is a villian? Why do so many people know Jenna Jameson’s name? Why do porn stars get their own awards show while prostitutes get their own jail cell? What is the difference? Where do we draw the line?

I’m really confused and curious about this. Am I missing something? If someone can come up with an explanation, please tell me.

~ Samantha

Comments

Wow this is a great post and a provocative question. The best explanation that I can come up with is

a) I think some of it is an question of image. A 44 year old woman down on her luck is less easy for people to identify with than a young, blond "actress"

b) Integration into society - porn stars often live secret lives that some may not even know they are a porn star whereas prostitutes are targets  

c) legislation - porn is legal and prostitution is still illegal. this may make it less easy for prostitutes to integrate themselves into society because they are decriminalized

d) sex positivity - it is viewed that prostitutes are more morally questionable because they complete the whole sex act whereas strippers and pornographers are offering a more visual product

# Posted By  vanessaaishacoleman | 2/10/10 03:43 PM | Report | Reply
I think the line that is not being drawn is including all forms of sex work as sex work (call girls, prostitues, pornographers, strippers, phone sex operators, etc.) I'd even go as far as to say that sexologists are sex workers.  There is a ridiculous heirarchy in the sex work field and that continues to marginalize prostitutes, especially street prostitutes.

Yes a camera does make a difference from a legal perspective in this country. It's based on "community standards," which has it's own set of problems, in my opinion. It's also based on capitalism and right now pornography makes more money for more people than prostitution does. After all, we live in a capitalist country where many of the laws are created to protect wealthy people with resources versus under-resourced and oppressed groups. Plus, a majority of people who consume and purchase pornography are not the people you think. Those people need to be "protected" from well judgment, other communities can be judged all the time (you can do the math to figure out which communities these are!).

PBS and Frontline had a great documentary that really highlights the connection between class, pornography consumption, and supply/demand. I suggest taking some time to watch it and check out the website they created for the program here.

Until people realize the inclusivity of the term "sex work" versus perpetuating a heirarchy there will be problems. Until people realize that there are some sex workers/specifically prostitutes who CHOOSE to be sex workers because they want to (not only because they have to or it is the only option for them but because it is the BEST option for them at this time and not vilifing them) and supporting people's decisions and meeting them where they are at (aka: harm reduction) there will be this issue. When people realize that it's not just women who are sex workers but people of all gender experssions and identities, then we can have a better conversation. When people are ready to realize the role racism plays in sex work as well as the intersectin of gender, disability, class, and ethnicity (i.e.the examples you used Hugh, Jenna et. al are all White people who are able-bodied) then a more fruitful discussion can occur. 

I consider myself a sex worker. Not just because i'm in the sex field, but because I too have worked with pornographers and major pornographic magazines in the US. I don't think there is a difference between the work I do and the work that any other sex worker does, it's just in a differen form of work but sex is at the center and we get paid for services.

# Posted By  Media_Justice | 2/10/10 10:08 PM | Report | Reply
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28            
The Celluloid Ceiling
By Culture_Voyeur
0 comments

What Do We Know About Open Relationships?
By Media_Justice
0 comments

Know your options. Respect them!
By Aye
0 comments

Naruto Shippuden!
By narutoandsoniclover
0 comments

A Step Backwards
By addiszemen
1 comments

Beijing +15
By pedlarm
0 comments

To abort? or not to abort? That is the question
By KarachiYWOCLC
1 comments

HIROSHIMA IMAGES-1 more to come.
By snorkamaiden
0 comments

Prom Cancelled Because a Girl Wanted to Bring Her Girlfriend
By RyAnYWOC
3 comments

My Love Letter to Feminism
By Jill
2 comments

Midwest Unite + Fight Conference is This Weekend
By Mahayana
0 comments

Utah: Prosecuting women is a “national model” for the anti-abortion movement
By AFY_Will
1 comments

Guest Post: The Fight for Sex Education in Utah
By Amplify_Staff
0 comments

24% of Young Adults Think 2 Condoms is Better!
By kirbygirl87
1 comments

Dentyne Ice Compares Gum to Condoms
By kirbygirl87
3 comments

Although there were bumps in the road, my distribution begins on Tuesday.
By YeseniaSuliveres
2 comments

Reflections on International Women’s Day: It’s Time to Get Current, Get Respect, and Get Inclusive
By Nicole
1 comments

Ad Tells Women: "Abortion Changes Things..."
By kirbygirl87
2 comments

Girl Child Education in Nigeria; Why Not?
By kiki
1 comments

iSEX
By TXCollegeGuy
1 comments

Youth Summit March 6
By KariG
2 comments

Pronouncement: For our autonomy and freedom!
By CeciGR
2 comments

Kenya: Victory for Anti-Abortion Lobby
By SPEAKLOUD
1 comments

Nicaragua's abortion ban preventing cancer patient from receiving necessary treatment
By SPEAKLOUD
3 comments

New Black Death?
By queencitystar
3 comments