Act
In The Culture
Issues
Campaigns
Support
About
Advocates For Youth
Who was robbed at this year's Oscars?
Avatar for Best Picture
Gabby Sidibe
Up in the Air for Adapted Screenplay
Anna Kendrick for Supporting Actress
Fantastic Mr. Fox for Best Animation
Johnny Weir! Still bitter.

You must be logged in to vote.
You must be logged in to vote




My Sistahs - A webite by and for young women of color
Youth Resource - A website by and for lgbtq youth
Advocates for Youth - A website for parents, health professionals and educators
AmbienteJoven.org 
Blog - Amplify your voice

Wednesday, November 19, 2008 at 7:27:00 PM EST
Rating:

 **SPOILER ALERT GALORE**

 

It’s Twilight time, baby.

 

Have you read it? Are you part of the drooling drove of fanpires who can’t get enough of Bella, Edward, Jacob and Forks WA? Do you dream of volturi, fast expensive cars and a love so pure it lasts a lifetime? Did I say lifetime? I meant eternity. Do you long for a werewolf best friend, vampire lover, and an omniscient personal stylist sister in law?

 

Or are you completely and utterly confused by this phenomenon? Do you not get the significance of South Park’s new vampire themed episode? Are you wondering why your fourteen year old cousin just changed her name to Bell?

 

I know, I know. This whole Twilight hysteria is leaving no one untouched. Even if you have no context for the book series, you probably know that the movie is coming out soon (FRIDAY) and some guy is stirring up a boy band caliber response. Young girls across the country are swooning over the idea of Edward, and Robert Pattinson has been cast to manifest that dream, while going deaf in the process.

 

Lest I lead you astray, I have already purchased my tickets for Thursday’s midnight showing of Twilight.

 

It didn’t really take much to convince me to read the series. As a rule, I love young adult fiction. Additionally, I love Harry Potter. As Twilight was being heralded as “the next Harry Potter,” how could I refuse? (I do, however, have some opinions about that designation.) I threw myself head first and surfaced about two weeks and almost 2,500 pages later. I remember putting down the last book, looking around my room and trying to remember the last time I ate a meal. It was that serious.

 

So I loved it, you know? It was a great ride. I laughed, I cried, I pined for Edward (and Alice, lets all be honest). But there was something I just couldn’t shake. Actually, there were a few things. Bella’s character troubled me. (As my roommate, who is reading it for the first time said to me this morning, “Does she really have to be carried everywhere?”) The relationship model the book presented disappointed me. (Eternal monogamy, anyone?) The treatment of the Quileute tribe angered me. (Did you know that they actually exist and have a reservation in La Push? Did you notice that, for the most part, they are the only people of color in the book? Did you notice that Stephanie Meyer makes them into WOLVES?) So here I am, trying to bask in the afterglow and I can’t stop thinking about how millions of young girls (and youth in general) are reading/obsessing over this book. What are the messages being sent to them about love, relationships, gender, sex, and race?

 

Bella is a wimpy heroine. There. I said it. Do with it what you will. She is plain yet beautiful. Smart yet quiet. Only gets into trouble to bring Edward back from his disappearance. Boooooring. Also, look at the men who surround her. Her father is a POLICE OFFICER. Her boyfriend is an immortal overprotective knight in shining armor on super speed. Her best friend is an enormous, equally protective, werewolf. Who needs to take care of themselves when the men in their life can do it for them? You must be kidding.

 

And she is sooooo in love with Edward. We’re talking, like, would do anything drop of a hat jump off a bridge in love. He is her everything. She bases her entire existence around him and ultimately sacrifices it to be with him. There is no doubt in her mind that he is her “one true love” and they are destined to be together forever. I’m sorry, but that’s gross.

 

Which brings me to the relationship model. All of the Cullens have their “other half.” Carlisle and Esme, Jasper and Alice, Emmet and Rosalie, and poor sullen single Edward. Also, lets not forget about werewolf imprinting. (At some point, the wolf boys “imprint” on a girl that they may or may not know and become inexorably in love with them. Some imprint on girls their own age, some imprint on toddlers, and some imprint on half humans half vampires.) When the wolfieboys imprint on someone young they take a paternal, nurturing role, which gradually blends into a best friend, which will inevitably become romantic investment. Between the werewolves and the vampires we are taught one thing: True love is found with one person (of the opposite sex), and if it is true, will and should last a lifetime. Did I say lifetime, again?

 

So what has Twilight taught our youth?

  1. Women must be cared for by men.
  2. They must sacrifice everything for love.
  3. Ideal relationships are heterosexual.
  4. Ideal relationships are ETERNALLY MONOGAMOUS.

 

 

Can you tell that #4 really gets me going? I’d like to flush out the idea of eternal monogamy more, but this post is running on too long already. Keep a look out for part II where I will talk about the movie (as I will have seen it), eternal monogamy (duh), race, and the moral neutrality achieved in the midst of potentially amoral subject matter (vampires=evil).

 

Who else will be at the theater tomorrow night? See you there!

 

xx

 

Comments
I read a story about it in the Washington Post and couldn't have felt more old and out of touch, as I had never heard of it before. Where the hell have I been? I need to check it out before my hipness meter drops off the charts...
# Posted By  AFY_Joe | 11/19/08 07:59 PM | Report | Reply
 I agree 100%.
Personally, Twilight doesn't do it for me as much as Harry Potter because
1) Its redeeming qualities lie completely in how attractive the vampires seem.
2) The writing just isn't that good.
3) Bella is, as you pointed out, a weak heroine (especially compared to, say, Hermione.)
But I also think the abstinence-advocacy component of Twilight is important to note.  The author's Mormonism was SO obvious to me as I read the book...I feel like they definitely would not have waited that long to have sex had the author not have had an abstinence-infused agenda.

# Posted By  Leah627 | 11/20/08 10:18 PM | Report | Reply
anybody see the movie yet? thoughts?
# Posted By  AFY_Joe | 11/21/08 08:35 PM | Report | Reply
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30            
Girl Child Education in Nigeria; Why Not?
By kiki
0 comments

iSEX
By TXCollegeGuy
0 comments

Youth Summit March 6
By KariG
0 comments

Pronouncement: For our autonomy and freedom!
By CeciGR
1 comments

Kenya: Victory for Anti-Abortion Lobby
By SPEAKLOUD
1 comments

Nicaragua's abortion ban preventing cancer patient from receiving necessary treatment
By SPEAKLOUD
1 comments

New Black Death?
By queencitystar
1 comments

Spring Break Stop
By healthyhatters
0 comments

February-- Wrap it before you tap it
By healthyhatters
0 comments

We're launching StandForUganda.com today. Will you help us spread the word?
By AFY_Nikki
1 comments

International Women’s Day 2010: Unity in Purpose…we sure can!
By Aye
1 comments

Progress for ALL women
By robocoko
1 comments

Happy International Women's Day!
By AFY_Nikki
0 comments

Abstinence-only programs are NOT health care reform
By Amplify_Staff
0 comments

You Did It: Utah legislature withdraws "criminal miscarriage" bill
By Amplify_Staff
1 comments

Spring Break 2010- USE CONDOMS!!!
By Mommy_2_An_Angel
0 comments

International Women's Day
By elizabeth
0 comments

Eliminating Health Barriers
By uncstudent88
1 comments

Roethlisberger, Rape Claims, and (A Dangerous Lack Of) Reason
By Yes_Means_Yes
2 comments

Sally's Home Abortion
By sshedgehog2
1 comments

I came out of the closet!
By narutoandsoniclover
3 comments

{It Is In You} Performance Video-Amplify Exclusive
By dandaman6007
0 comments

Some Light Reading
By hopeistheanswer
1 comments

Who cares that Patrick Murphy is married?
By Mahayana
1 comments

Hi! from France =)
By johan08
1 comments